On 31
August 2026, by a decision of a Vladikavkaz court, Abkhaz journalist Nizfa
Arshba was fined 30,000 roubles, approximately 353 US dollars. According to the
court, Arshba shared material on the social media platform Facebook without the
notice required under Russian law indicating that the material had been created
or distributed by a foreign agent or concerned the activities of a foreign
agent.
The
ruling issued by a Russian court against Abkhaz journalist Nizfa Arshba has
once again raised the question: where does Russian jurisdiction end, and where
does the personal and legal sphere of people living in a territory that is not
legally part of the Russian Federation begin?
However,
other circumstances in this case are more significant than the amount of the
fine itself: Arshba is not a Russian citizen, has never lived in Russia and,
according to her, has no legal or residential ties to the country. Moreover,
the journalist learnt about the court’s decision by chance, through the
internet.
Nizfa
Arshba is an opposition journalist and the author of the Telegram channel
“Aiashara”. The Russian Ministry of Justice placed her on the register of
“foreign agents” back in March 2025, immediately after the conclusion of the
so-called presidential elections held in Abkhazia. The Russian authorities’
decision is linked to the journalist’s activities and public positions. Arshba
has repeatedly spoken out against draft laws and Russia-Abkhazia agreements
which, in her assessment, ran counter to Abkhazia’s interests. For taking
similar positions, two Abkhaz politicians, Kan Kvarchia and Leon Miqaa, were
stripped of their Russian citizenship, while three journalists, including
Arshba, were placed on the register of foreign agents.
In
Russia, legislation on “foreign agents” was initially focused on issues related
to foreign funding and influence over the activities of organisations and
individuals. However, over time, its scope has expanded significantly. Once a
person is designated a foreign agent, they are subject to a range of
obligations, including the requirement to publish public statements, materials
shared on social media and other information with a special label. It was
precisely the violation of this requirement that the Russian court accused
Nizfa Arshba of.
The
problem, however, is that the Russian authorities have imposed these
requirements on a person who is not a Russian citizen and does not reside on
Russian territory. A violation of this requirement carries a fine, while
repeated violations may also result in criminal liability. In practice, this
“label” means stigmatisation and persecution.
For
residents of Abkhazia, this has an additional consequence: a de facto
restriction on freedom of movement. Russia is the most accessible destination
for travelling abroad, and the route to the “wider world” also passes through
it. However, people designated as “foreign agents” avoid travelling to Russia,
and their ability to travel to other countries is also restricted.
Under
these circumstances, the main question remains: how and why did a
Vladikavkaz court hear a case involving a citizen of a foreign country?
The
court’s decision states that the journalist did not attend the hearing and did
not provide a reason for her absence. At the same time, the court maintains
that she had been informed of the proceedings and that a notification had been
sent to her residential address in the Russian Federation. However, according
to Arshba, the address in question is unknown to her, as she has never lived in
Russia.
Arshba
is solely a citizen of de facto Abkhazia. Unlike her colleague Izida Chania, who holds dual Abkhaz-Russian
citizenship, Arshba has never had any legal ties to Russia. Accordingly, the
notification procedure could not apply to her. Russian citizens, including those
placed on the register, receive notifications of fines through their personal
accounts on the “State Services” portal. Arshba is neither a citizen nor a
resident and is therefore not registered on the portal. Consequently, she could
not have received the notification.
Formally,
this approach is based on the extraterritorial application of Russian
legislation: anyone placed on the register becomes subject to Russian legal
requirements, regardless of their place of residence, citizenship or wishes.
Beyond these formalities, however, this arrangement has no genuine legal basis.
A person who is not subject to Russian jurisdiction is punished on the basis of
a letter sent to a non-existent address.
Arshba
does not intend to pay the fine. However, this precedent could have serious
consequences: repeated violations of the “foreign agents” law could expose her
to criminal liability. At present, she faces no threat from the local
authorities in Abkhazia itself, but the authorities remain silent on the issue.
The
case of a single independent journalist demonstrates what Russian influence
looks like in the occupied territories. Occupied Abkhazia is officially
referred to as an “independent state”, yet Russia’s repressive apparatus treats
its citizens as though they were subject to Russian jurisdiction. A Vladikavkaz
court punishes a person who has no ties to Russia through citizenship,
residence or any legal obligation.
Russia’s
influence over Abkhazia is often examined from a military, economic or
political perspective. The case of Nizfa Arshba, however, reveals another
dimension of this influence — the legal one.
When a
Kremlin court fines a foreign citizen who has never lived on Russian territory
for a social media post, the issue is no longer merely about the punishment of
a single journalist. It demonstrates how far Russia’s legal and political
influence can extend into territories that are controlled by Russia but are not
part of Russia under international law.
ოკუპირებულ აფხაზეთში რუსეთის მიერ წარმოებული პასპორტიზაციის პოლიტიკა ახალ, გაცილებით აგრესიულ ფაზაში შედის.
Recently, Russia has been actively seeking to bring the issue of the occupied territories to the forefront and to secure their legal separation from Georgia.
In Georgia, while 2024–2026 is described as a period of significant deterioration in media rights, signs of increased state-led political influence over independent and public-interest media had become visible earlier.